5 Common fraud schemes and how title agents can avoid them.

Stay ahead of risk with practical fraud prevention tips and trusted tools.

TL;DR:

• Seller impersonation fraud targets vacant or rental properties; verify identity and deed history carefully.
• Wire fraud and email spoofing exploit unsecured communication; use encrypted portals and verify instructions by phone.
• Forged releases and payoff fraud involve fake lien satisfactions; confirm payoffs with known contacts and secure platforms.
• Notary and ID fraud uses falsified documents; vet notaries and educate clients on proper ID verification.
• AI-driven deepfake scams impersonate trusted parties; authenticate identities outside digital channels and slow down urgent requests.

Fraud in the title industry isn’t new – but it is evolving. Fraudsters have become more sophisticated and are continually looking to exploit weak links in the transaction chain. As title professionals, we are the guardians of trust and transparency in real estate, which makes us both a line of defense and a primary target.

Here are some of the most common fraud schemes impacting our industry today – and actionable ways to prevent them.

1.     Seller Impersonation Fraud

What it is: Criminals pose as the legitimate owner of a property – often vacant land or rental property – and attempt to sell it without the true owner’s knowledge. These scams can be difficult to detect because everything looks above board until it’s too late.

How to avoid it:

• Verify identity thoroughly. Insist on in-person notarization or use a vetted remote online notarization (RON) platform that includes strong identity verification.
• Be cautious with vacant land or investment property sales. If the seller is out of state or only available via email or text, dig deeper.
• Check recent deed history. Watch for quick or unusual transfers that may indicate fraud.
• Call the last known owner at a publicly listed number. A quick conversation could save the entire transaction.

2.     Wire Fraud and Email Spoofing

What it is: Fraudsters hack into email accounts or impersonate trusted parties, such as agents, buyers, or escrow officers, to redirect wire transfers to fraudulent accounts – often within hours of closing.

How to avoid it:

• Use encrypted email or secure portals for wiring instructions. Never send or accept wire instructions over regular email.
• Establish a “call-before-you-wire” policy. Instruct clients to always verify wiring instructions by calling a trusted number, not the one in the suspicious email.
• Train your staff regularly. Simulated phishing tests and fraud training can build awareness and reduce risk.

3.     Forged Releases or Payoff Fraud

What it is: A fraudster records a fake satisfaction or release of a lien or mortgage to make it appear clear when it’s not. Alternatively, they provide fake payoff instructions to divert funds.

How to avoid it:

• Verify payoffs with known contacts. Always use verified phone numbers – not the ones provided in the new document or email.
• Use secure wire platforms for payoffs. Systems that authenticate recipients reduce risk.
• Check the public record carefully. Review recent releases and cross-check signatures with prior documents.

4.     Notary and ID Fraud

What it is: Fraudulent notaries or falsified identifications can result in forged documents being recorded or accepted at closing.

How to avoid it:

• Vet your notaries. Use known and trusted notaries or remote online notarization (RON) providers that verify ID with biometric or multi-step authentication.
• Look for red flags. Uneven signatures, expired IDs, or “urgent” closing timelines can signal fraud.
• Educate clients. Help them understand why identity verification matters and what it looks like when it’s done right.

5.     Deepfake and AI-Generated Impersonation Scams

What it is: With the rise of AI tools, fraudsters are now using synthetic voice technology, fake video calls, and AI-generated documents to impersonate real estate professionals, attorneys, or even clients. These schemes are used to alter transaction instructions, divert funds, or rush closings under false pretenses.

How to avoid it:

• Authenticate outside the screen. If something feels off during a video call or phone conversation, such as an unnatural-sounding voice or generic background images, take extra steps to verify the person's identity through a separate channel you already trust.
• Use multi-factor authentication. Especially for systems used to send or approve wiring instructions, document signings, or disbursements.
• Slow down high-pressure situations. Fraudsters often push for quick closings or changes under the guise of urgency. Require extra steps when sudden changes are requested, especially involving funding or signatories.

Leverage powerful tools to stay ahead of fraud.

First American Title offers innovative fraud prevention solutions to help title agents protect transactions with greater confidence, including the SAFEvalidation® service, SAFEidentify™, and Order Insights.

The SAFEvalidation service verifies wire instructions using proprietary technology that authenticates account ownership without requiring input from the payee – making the process both faster and more secure.

SAFEidentify adds another layer of protection by validating contact information such as phone numbers, emails, and addresses in seconds, helping agents detect impersonation attempts early.

Order Insights is a real-time, transaction-based fraud alert system designed to help title agents reduce fraud risk. Data is automatically validated as transactions are entered into AgentNet® Services, and agents receive notifications of discrepancies or potential fraud indicators.

These tools are integrated into First American Title’s underwriting services at no additional charge, reinforcing our shared commitment to safeguarding every transaction. By partnering with First American Title, agents gain access to advanced fraud detection technology and a trusted ally in the fight against evolving threats.

Security is everyone’s job.

Fraud prevention isn’t just a set of policies – it’s a culture. Agencies that create a consistent, security-minded workflow are far less likely to fall victim. Share fraud stories at team meetings, run mock scenarios, and encourage staff to raise red flags. The more eyes on a transaction, the better.

And remember, when in doubt – pause. A delayed closing is always better than a compromised one.

Looking for more education and support?

If you're already a First American Title agent, click here to explore AgentNet Knowledge for powerful underwriting content and education for title agents.

Not yet a First American Title agent? Click here to partner with us and grow your business with confidence.